
Way back in the cobwebs of my high school memories, there was a moment in one particular class when the teacher said, "Don't worry about why you work the problem this way—just do it the way I showed you." Those instructions were my worst nightmare. Don't try to understand why. I never could learn anything that way. To have any hope of remembering enough information to pass the test (and I was very focused on passing the test:), I had to understand why not just what. Later, as a magazine writer, I was the same way—I guess all writers are. You can't tell the story until you fully understand it.
That's why I relate so well to the confusion and dismay of the disciples when Jesus calmed the stormy sea (Mark 4:35-41). They were out in a boat with Jesus when a terrible squall blew in, and the waves were crashing over, threatening to capsize them. All the while, Jesus was sleeping. When they woke him up, they were frightened and clearly aggravated: "Teacher, don't you care if we drown?" Jesus calmed the storm, and here's what followed:
He said to his disciples,
"Why are you so afraid? Do you still have no faith?"
They were terrified and asked each other,
"Who is this? Even the wind and the waves obey him!"
I just read a wonderful interpretation of this passage in Reverend Timothy Keller's The King's Cross: The Story of the World in the Life of Jesus:
"This picture goes to our hearts, because everyone who's ever tried to live a life of faith in this world has felt like this sometimes. Everything is going wrong, you're sinking, and God seems to be asleep, absent, or unaware. If you loved us, the disciples are saying, you wouldn't let us go through this. If you loved us, we wouldn't be about to sink. If you loved us, you would not be letting us endure deadly peril. Jesus calmed the storm, and then he responded to them. Did he say, I can understand how you felt? No, he asked, 'Why are you so afraid?' . . .
"Jesus's question to them has behind it this thought: Your premise is wrong. You should have known better. I do allow people I love to go through storms. You had no reason to panic. . . ."
Here's one of the powerful conclusions Reverend Keller draws from this event: "If you have a God great enough and powerful enough to be mad at because he doesn't stop your suffering, you also have a God who's great enough and powerful enough to have reasons you can't understand. You can't have it both ways."
Just because I can't see the plan, that doesn't mean there isn't one. Just because I don't understand the reasons, that doesn't mean they aren't there. God doesn't always give us the answers in boldfaced type. But if you examine your own past, your own path, you can see that it was mapped out for the good—and you can trust that you'll have sufficient grace to get through whatever tests lie ahead—even those dreadful pop quizzes that take you completely by surprise.
Timothy Keller, The King's Cross: The Story of the World in the LIfe of Jesus (Dutton, 2011), pp. 53-54